Main Page

From Who Comments? - the encyclopedia of comment & opinion
Jump to: navigation, search
the encyclopedia of comment & opinion
the UK's only free to use biographical database of comment journalism
1,305 articles in English
Business and Finance Culture and Media Economy and Employment Education and Training
Environment and Resources EU and World Affairs Government and Politics Health and Welfare
Infrastructure and Transport Law and Security Science and Technology Society and Values
The Daily Telegraph · The Sunday Telegraph · The Times · The Sunday Times · The Guardian · The Observer · The Independent · The Independent on Sunday
Daily Mail · The Mail on Sunday · Daily Express · Sunday Express · The Sun · Daily Mirror · Sunday Mirror · Daily Star · Evening Standard · Morning Star
Financial Times · The Wall Street Journal · Reuters BreakingViews · The Economist · Investors Chronicle
UK broadcast · UK magazines · UK regional journals · US journals · US magazines · From around the world
Political/Economic organisations · Academics · Political bloggers · Bloggers · Correspondents · Politicians · Unaffiliated/Freelance · Journalist roles
featured article(s)

"Jas" illustrations

George Monbiot: Eat Meat and Save the World?

Allan Savory tells us that increasing livestock numbers can reduce desertification and reverse climate change – but where is the scientific evidence?

4th August 2014

It doesn’t matter how often miracles are disproved; our willingness to believe in them remains undiminished. Miracle cures, miracle crops, miracle fuels, miracle financial instruments, miracle profits: the continued enthusiasm for these claims reflects the triumph of hope over experience.

Here’s another one: a miracle technique that allows us to reconcile our insatiable demand for meat with the need to protect the living planet. Better still, it proposes, eating meat could actually save the biosphere. A TED talk which makes this claim has been viewed 2.6 million times.

Over the weekend in London, the author of this talk, Allan Savory, convened an international conference, in which a long list of speakers lined up to insist that his methods have been vindicated.

I was intrigued by his TED talk, in which he screened astonishing before-and-after pictures purporting to show the transformative impacts of his technique. Mr Savory maintained that without grazing by livestock, grasslands turn to desert. He claimed that he had reversed desertification by raising the number of cattle and goats by 400%, grazing them intensively for short bursts in small paddocks and then moving them on.

By this means, he said, the hooves of the animals break up what he calls the “cancer of desertification”: the crust of algae that forms on bare soil in dry areas. Breaking it up, he claimed, encourages the growth of grass. By trampling vegetation and coating it with manure, the livestock produce a mulch that ensures the soil absorbs and retains more water.

As a result of this transformation, we can do something astonishing:

“we can take enough carbon out of the atmosphere and safely store it in the grassland soils for thousands of years, and if we just do that on about half the world’s grasslands that I’ve shown you, we can take us back to pre-industrial levels while feeding people. I can think of almost nothing that offers more hope for our planet, for your children, for their children and all of humanity.”

Mr Savory’s grazing technique, which he calls “holistic management”, could, in other words, reverse not only desertification but also climate change – while permitting us to keep consuming vast quantities of meat. No wonder it has been received with such enthusiasm.

I would love to believe him. But I’ve been in this game too long to take anything on trust – especially simple solutions to complex problems. So I went to the library and started reading. A large number of academic papers have been published in response to his claims, testing them by means of experimental and comparative studies. The conclusion, overwhelmingly, is that his statements are not supported by empirical evidence and experimental work, and that in crucial respects his techniques do more harm than good.

A new review of experimental results, in the journal Agricultural Systems, has this to say about Savory’s claims that his intensive rotational grazing (IRG) can regenerate grassland:

“The vast majority of experimental evidence does not support claims of enhanced ecological benefits in IRG compared to other grazing strategies, including the capacity to increase storage of soil organic carbon. … IRG has been rigorously evaluated, primarily in the US, by numerous investigators at multiple locations and in a wide range of precipitation zones over a period of several decades. Collectively, these experimental results clearly indicate that IRG does not increase plant or animal production, or improve plant community composition, or benefit soil surface hydrology compared to other grazing strategies”

Another review article, in the International Journal of Biodiversity, found that grazing by livestock in arid places is more likely to destroy grass and other vegetation than to protect it:

“Published comparisons of grazed and ungrazed lands in the western USA have found that rested sites have larger and more dense grasses, fewer weedy forbs and shrubs, higher biodiversity, higher productivity, less bare ground, and better water infiltration than nearby grazed sites.”

Among these sites was a ranch in Arizona whose vegetation, Savory had claimed, had become “moribund” and increasingly sparse since grazing there had ceased. In reality, there has been a massive increase in both plant cover and plant diversity on this site since the livestock were removed.

As for the claim that the algal crust is the “cancer of desertification”, it appears to be just the opposite: a rich, diverse and ancient ecosystem in its own right, that stabilises the soil, increases organic matter and absorbs water. These crusts are “fragile, highly susceptible to trampling, and are slow to recover from trampling impacts. Loss of these crusts results in increased erosion and reduced soil fertility.”

Overall, it concluded,

“Ecologically, the application of Holistic Management principles of trampling and intensive foraging are as detrimental to plants, soils, water storage, and plant productivity as are conventional grazing systems.”

So what exactly do Allan Savory’s dramatic pictures of transformation show? As they are uncaptioned and not linked in his presentations to scientific studies, it’s hard to tell. Many factors affect the way vegetation changes in arid places. Do these shifts really depict the results of the application of his techniques, or something else entirely?

As for the claim that Holistic Management can reverse the build-up of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, according to, he’s wrong by orders of magnitude. Just to balance current carbon emissions, the uptake of carbon by all the world’s vegetation (not only grasslands) would have to triple. But Savory says he can go beyond that, and his technique can bring atmospheric carbon “back to pre-industrial levels”. As RealClimate puts it, “science tells us that this claim is simply not reasonable.”

Far from grazing helping to store carbon, it seems to have the opposite effect: the evidence strongly suggests that livestock reduce carbon storage rather than raising it. In terms of total greenhouse gas emissions, the intensive grazing of cattle on grasslands can be even worse than producing them in feedlots.

While Allan was in London, I managed to secure a telephone interview with him, to ask him about these challenges. It did not go well. He began by comparing himself to Galileo, which is never a good sign, and it went downhill from there. I have learnt to be suspicious of people who give long, distracting, irrelevant answers to simple questions. Apart from Ian Plimer, I have never come across anyone who does it to greater effect.

I asked him about that ranch in Arizona, and the claim that he was diametrically wrong about what had happened to the vegetation once grazing had ceased. He launched into a long disquisition about a court case in Namibia. After several attempts I at last managed to break in, to remind him I’d asked about a ranch in Arizona. It was as if he registered the name of the state and nothing else: he started talking about the quality of the state’s scientists, its rifle ranges and its tortoises.

I asked him about his carbon claims. He told me it wasn’t him who had made such claims, but other people who knew far more about it than he did. Could he gave me the names of those people?

He gave me a long, rambling answer about the different impacts of land management around the world, climate change, fire, poverty, violence, red meat and veganism. I tried and tried again. At last I managed to bring him round to the question, and extracted some names from him. So where had they published their calculations? They hadn’t.

His staff later sent me an article on the issue published on the Savory Institute’s website, but – as far as I can tell – nowhere else. There are no named authors. If you intend to make a massive and extraordinary scientific claim, and build your position around it, you had better ensure that it has been properly tested, which is why the peer review process exists.

Broadly, however, his theme was that what scientists were studying was not the entirety of Holistic Management, but only one aspect of it:

“It’s like having a plane that flies that lands on 3 wheels, and we’ve only had wheelbarrows or tricycles for centuries and so people are studying the tricycle and saying well it’s got three wheels, and it we cannot make it fly; it can’t fly. How come the plane the can fly when it’s also got three wheels?”

Allan referred me to a paper he’d written, which he said, explains the science and methodology of holistic grazing. This paper (again apparently unpublished except on his website) explained the lack of scientific support for his claims as follows:

“Holistic Management does not permit replication. Because of this fact we can only validate the ‘science’ used and monitor or document ‘results achieved’. Note: This point is critical to understanding the great difficulty reductionist scientists are experiencing trying to comprehend holistic planned grazing – because no two plans are ever the same even on the same property two years running, planned grazing cannot be replicated which reductionist scientists do to try to understand the ‘science.’”

It then contended that:

“The only independent assessment of all available critics and their citations was done by Chris Gill. Gill, involved in management and with a liberal arts education, studied every citation he could locate and who in turn those authors cited. As he reports not a single paper discrediting Holistic Management actually studied, or even attempted to study, holistic planned grazing.”

Unfortunately Savory gives no reference for this assessment. In the academic literature, I’ve been unable to find a paper on the subject by anyone called Gill. Elsewhere, all I have been able to locate is a 3-page magazine article by Chris Gill, reproduced on Savory’s websites. It contains no references, no data and no links to any experimental or empirical research. If this is “the only independent assessment of all available critics and their citations” that Savory will accept as valid, I think it might tell you something about the substance of his claims.

It all reminds me, I’m afraid, of the way in which certain evangelists for alternative medicine operate.

For example:

- Savory maintains that it’s not the claims that are wrong but the scientific process by which they are assessed. (In one interview he says “you’ll find the scientific method never discovers anything.”)

- He claims that “reductionist science” doesn’t understand what Holistic Management involves, which is why it fails to measure the outcomes properly. But, as Adam Merberg points out, his account of what Holistic Management means appears inconsistent and poorly defined, which “allows Savory to blame any failures on a misunderstanding of the method.”

- As scientific studies don’t produce the results he wants, he relies instead on testimonials.

- He diagnoses normal conditions as deadly pathologies (“the cancer of desertification”) then claims to have found a cure for them.

- He makes claims about his techniques which are not only implausible but appear to be scientifically impossible.

It seems to me that there’s a fairly solid rule, that applies to almost any question: what you want to believe is almost always wrong. If something sounds too good to be true, that’s because, in nearly all cases, it is.


David Aaronovitch · Accountancy Column · Guy Adams · Kamal Ahmed · Decca Aitkenhead · Yasmin Alibhai-Brown · Arne Alsin · Chris Ames · Nigel Andrews · Anjana Ahuja · Andrew Alexander · James Altucher · Matthew d'Ancona · Bruce Anderson · Andrew Anthony · Louise Armitstead · Sue Arnold · Rob Arnott · Charles Arthur · Neal Ascherson · Jackie Ashley · Tim Ashley · Anne Ashworth · Peter Aspden · Mike Atherton · Dan Atkinson · Mark Austin · John Authers · Chris Ayres · Lisa Bachelor · The Backbencher · Julian Baggini · Gerard Baker · Martin Baker · Joan Bakewell · Martin Baker · Baz Bamigboye · Annalisa Barbieri · Patrick Barclay · Patrick Barkham · Simon Barnes · James Bartholomew · Sandra Barwick · Claire Beale · Mary Beard · Rosemary Behan · Emily Bell · Steve Bell · Catherine Bennett · Oliver Bennett · Vanora Bennett · Marcus Berkmann · Marcel Berlins · Peter Bill · Michael Billington · Peter Bills · Ian Birrell · Patrick Bishop · Bizarre · Ian Black · Black Dog · Virginia Blackburn · Terence Blacker · Blackfriar · David Blackwell · James Blitz · Phillip Blond · David Blunkett · David Bolchover · Anthony Bolton · Christopher Booker · Roger Bootle · Julian Borger · Mark Borkowski · Mihir Bose · David Bowen · Geoffrey Boycott · Rosie Boycott · Susie Boyt · Pierre Briançon · Simon Briscoe · Samuel Brittan · Benedict Brogan · Charlie Brooker · Libby Brooks · Andy Brough · Andrew Brown · Cooper Brown · Craig Brown · Maggie Brown · Michael Brown · Tyler Brûlé · Alex Brummer · Kirsty Buchanan · Willem Buiter · Andrew Buncombe · Madeleine Bunting · Julie Burchill · Oliver Burkeman · Bill Burrows · Katherine Butler · Siobhain Butterworth · Vince Cable · Carole Cadwalladr · Christopher Caldwell · Sue Cameron · Georgia Cameron-Clarke · Beatrix Campbell · Duncan Campbell · Ian Campbell · Paul Carr · Simon Carr · Rory Carroll · Sue Carroll · Simon Caulkin · Camilla Cavendish · Alexander Chancellor · Shami Chakrabarti · Edward Chancellor · Peter Chapman · Angelique Chrisafis · Rupert Christiansen · Ben Chu · Ross Clark · Tom Clark · Jane Clarke · Mickey Clarke · Peter Clarke · Jeremy Clarkson · Charles Clover · Alan Cochrane · Patrick Cockburn · Philip Coggan · Nick Cohen · Robert Cole · Neil Collins · Patrick Collinson · Robert Colvile · Heather Connon · Steve Connor · Edmund Conway · Jonathan Cook · Nicola Copping · Alan Coren · Giles Coren · Victoria Coren · Rupert Cornwell · Tracy Corrigan · Ros Coward · Ian Cowie · Con Coughlin · David Cox · Robert Crampton · Agnes T. Crane · Clive Crook · Cross Bencher · Antony Currie · Robert Cyran · Iain Dale · James Daley · Janet Daley · Philippa Davenport · Jenny Davey · Andrew Davidson · Gavyn Davies · Nick Davies · Clive Davis · Rowenna Davis · Michael Deacon · Bill Deedes · Henry Deedes · Chris Deerin · Mary Dejevsky · James Delingpole · Mick Dennis · Dominik Diamond · John Dillon · Chris Dillow · Hugo Dixon · John Dizard · Peter Dobbie · Daniel Dombey · Richard Donkin · Tim Dowling · Margaret Doyle · Oliver Duff · Nicholas Dunbar · Gary Duncan · Emma Duncan · Kevin Eason · David Edgar · Simon Edge · David Edwards · John Edwards · Barbara Ellen · Keith Elliott · Larry Elliott · Tracey Emin · Engaging India · Matthew Engel · European View · Harold Evans · Ambrose Evans-Pritchard · Hermione Eyre · Harry Eyres · James Le Fanu · Nigel Farndale · Paul Farrow · Guido Fawkes · Mick Fealty · Vanessa Feltz · Euan Ferguson · Niall Ferguson · Nick Ferrari · Helen Fielding · Christopher Fildes · Julia Finch · Daniel Finkelstein · Robert Fisk · Richard Fletcher · John Foley · Stephen Foley · Frederick Forsyth · Peter Franklin · Alexandra Frean · Jonathan Freedland · Chrystia Freeland · Hadley Freeman · Vanessa Friedman · Frank Furedi · Una Galani · Gregor Gall · John Gapper · Richard Garner · Timothy Garton Ash · Jasper Gerard · Frances Gibb · Janine Gibson · A A Gill · Andrew Gilligan · Andrew Gimson · John Gittings · Dan Glaister · Jonathan Glancey · Julian Glover · Stephen Glover · Tanya Gold · Ben Goldacre · Suzanne Goldenberg · David Goodhart · Bryony Gordon · Richard Gott · Michael Gove · Andrew Gowers · Linda Grant · John Gray · David Green · Roy Greenslade · Andrew Grice · Viv Groskop · Wei Gu · Jon Guant · Francesco Guerrera · Katy Guest · Jonathan Guthrie · Anthony Haden-Guest · Macer Hall · Liam Halligan · Tim Hames · Adrian Hamilton · Neil Hamilton · Daniel Hannan · Ephraim Hardcastle · James Harding · Luke Harding · Tim Harford · Deborah Hargreaves · Johann Hari · John Harris · Julia Hartley-Brewer · Max Hastings · Simon Hattenstone · Roy Hattersley · George Hay · Natalie Haynes · Edward Heathcoat-Amory · Simon Heffer · Adam Helliker · Michael Henderson · Jon Henley · Philip Hensher · Noreena Hertz · Steve Hewlett · William Hickey · Andrew Hill · Dave Hill · Anthony Hilton · Isabel Hilton · Gaby Hinsliff · Christopher Hitchens · Peter Hitchens · Lydia Hislop · Phil Hogan · Simon Hoggart · Jim Holden · Oliver Holt · Lawrie Homes · Patrick Hosking · Anthony Howard · Christopher Howse · Polly Hudson · David Hughes · Mick Hume · Liz Hunt · Tristram Hunt · Martin Hutchinson · Will Hutton · Marina Hyde · Armando Iannucci · John Ingham · Richard Ingrams · Edwina Ings-Chambers · Inside Curve · Jill Insley · Jonathan Isaby · Martin Ivens · Ian Jack · Tony Jackson · Howard Jacobson · Martin Jacques · Alex James · Erwin James · Alice-Azania Jarvis · Jeff Jarvis · Stuart Jeffries · Simon Jenkins · Boris Johnson · Frank Johnson · Jo Johnson · Luke Johnson · Rachel Johnson · Philip Johnston · Dom Joly · Dylan Jones · Jonathan Jones · Liz Jones · Nicholas De Jongh · Guy de Jonquières · Stephen Kahn · Anatole Kaletsky · Oliver Kamm · John Kampfner · Anne Karpf · Vitaliy Katsenelson · Sunder Katwala · Trevor Kavanagh · John Kay · Richard Kay · William Kay · John Keegan · William Keegan · Andrew Keen · Lucy Kellaway · Des Kelly · Lorraine Kelly · Martin Kelner · Mary Kenny · Tessa Keswick · Martin Kettle · Roula Khalaf · Ian King · Stephen King · Miles Kington · Mark Kleinman · India Knight · Julian Knight · Marek Kohn · Paul Krugman · Simon Kuper · Nicholas Lander · Robin Lane Fox · William Langley · Robert Gore-Langton · Jeremy Laurance · Dominic Lawson · Mark Lawson · Ruth Lea · Geoffrey Lean · Norman Lebrecht · Rowley Leigh · Sam Leith · Tom Leonard · Ann Leslie · Quentin Letts · Ariel Leve · Ellie Levenson · Jemima Lewis · William Lewis · Lex column · John Lichfield · Rod Liddle · Magnus Linklater · Maureen Lipman · David Lister · Bel Littlejohn · Richard Littlejohn · Lombard · Simon London · John Lloyd · Dan de Luce · Martin Lukes · Neil Lyndon · Ben Macintyre · Donald Macintyre · Kelvin Mackenzie · Stuart Maconie · Denis MacShane · Bronwen Maddox · Kevin Maguire · Fiona Maharg-Bravo · Victor Mallet · Carole Malone · Mandrake · Lucy Mangan · Clinton Manning · Christopher Manthorp · Andrew Marr · Oliver Marre · Minette Marrin · Iain Martin · Jurek Martin · Jane Martinson · Jenny McCartney · Margaret McCartney · Melanie McDonagh · Anne McElvoy · Richard McGregor · Fiona McIntosh · Peter McKay · David McKie · Robin McKie · Leo McKinstry · Hamish McRae · Adrian Michaels · Carol Midgley · Neil Midgley · Alice Miles · David Miller · Eleanor Mills · Seumas Milne · Jan Moir · George Monbiot · Mrs Moneypenny · Bel Mooney · Charles Moore · James Moore · Jane Moore · Suzanne Moore · Caitlin Moran · Piers Morgan · Richard Morrison · Carl Mortished · Ferdinand Mount · Harry Mount · Hugh Muir · Wolfgang Münchau · Chris Mullin · Andrew Murray-Watson · Jonathan Myerson · Julie Myerson · John Naughton · Charles Nevin · T.N. Ninan · Jason Nisse · Matthew Norman · Richard Norton-Taylor · Notebook · Peter Oborne · Cristina Odone · John O'Farrell · Patrick O'Flynn · Sean O'Grady · Andrew O'Hagan · Jonathan Oliver · On the press · On Wall Street · Deborah Orr · Hugh O'Shaughnessy · Margareta Pagano · Nicholas Paisner · Greg Palast · Alasdair Palmer · Pandora · George Parker · Matthew Parris · Sandra Parsons · Tony Parsons · Nick Paton Walsh · Christina Patterson · John Patterson · Allison Pearson · Quentin Peel · Rowan Pelling · Pendennis · Robert Peston · Peterborough · James Pethokoukis · Alexis Petridis · Fiona Phillips · Melanie Phillips · Justine Picardie · Anna Pickard · Jim Pickard · Andrew Pierce · John Pilger · David Pilling · Stephen Pincock · George Pitcher · Amanda Platell · John Plender · Martin Plimmer · Agnès Poirier · Stephen Pollard · Mary Portas · Andrew Porter · Henry Porter · Michael Portillo · Jeff Powell · Nils Pratley · Michael Prest · Peter Preston · Charles Pretzlik · Lance Price · Oliver Pritchett · Property Column · David Prosser · Libby Purves · Dina Rabinovitch · Gideon Rachman · Naresh Ramchandani · Jeff Randall · Esther Rantzen · Charlotte Raven · Andrew Rawnsley · Brian Reade · Damian Reece · William Rees-Mogg · Melanie Reid · John Rentoul · Richard & Judy · Steve Richards · John Richardson · Mary Riddell · Peter Riddell · Hugo Rifkind · Rosemary Righter · Dan Roberts · Jancis Robinson · Nick Robinson · David Robson · Kenneth Rogoff · Jon Ronson · Amy Rosenthal · Deborah Ross · James Rossiter · Paul Routledge · David Rowan · Joshua Rozenberg · Alec Russell · Jenni Russell · Dan Sabbagh · Lina Saigol · Martin Samuel · Sarah Sands · Sathnam Sanghera · Carol Sarler · Jack Schofield · Maria Scott · Jeremy Seabrook · Adrian Searle · Will Self · Mark Sellers · Jennifer Selway · David Sexton · Tom Shakespeare · Fergus Shanahan · David Shand · Chris Shaw · Jim Shelley · Adam Sherwin · Jane Shilling · Phil Shiner · Robert Shrimsley · Lionel Shriver · Alexandra Shulman · Larry Siedentop · Mary Ann Sieghart · Lucy Siegle · Lauren Silva Laughlin · Gary Silverman · Rachel Simhon · Stefan Simanowitz · Emma Simon · Alex Singleton · Michael Skapinker · Robert Skidelsky · Pauline Skypala · Adam Smart · Alexander Smith · Anna Smith · David Smith · Delia Smith · Giles Smith · Joan Smith · Raymond Snoddy · Dan Snow · Merryn Somerset Webb · Mike Southon · The Spoon · Paul Staines · Mark Steel · Jonathan Steele · Irwin Stelzer · Philip Stephens · Stefan Stern · Tom Stevenson · Graham Stewart · Mark Steyn · Joseph Stiglitz · Peter Stothard · Richard Stott · Janet Street-Porter · Thomas Stuttaford · Andrew Sullivan · Lawrence Summers · Ben Summerskill · Ruth Sunderland · Thomas Sutcliffe · John Sutherland · Henry Sutton · Christopher Swann · Matthew Syed · Rachel Sylvester · Matthew Taylor · Paul Taylor · Gillian Tett · Daniel Thomas · Lesley Thomas · Damian Thompson · Alice Thomson · Barbara Toner · Thunderer · Whitney Tilson · Sylvia Tidy-Harris · Simon Tisdall · Alan Titchmarsh · Michael Tomasky · Richard Tomkins · Catherine Townsend · Martin Townsend · Nick Townsend · Polly Toynbee · John Train · John Travers · Ian Traynor · George Trefgarne · Giles Tremlett · Ann Treneman · Janice Turner · Rebecca Tyrrel · Ulrika · Neil Unmack · Maggie Urry · David Usborne · Tom Utley · Dominic Utton · Matthew Vincent · Brian Viner · Celia Walden · George Walden · Patti Waldmeir · David Walker · John Walsh · Natasha Walter · John Waples · Jeremy Warner · Keith Waterhouse · Alan Watkins · Shane Watson · Jonathan Watts · Paul Waugh · Jacob Weisberg · Ed West · Michael Wharton · Geoffrey Wheatcroft · Patience Wheatcroft · Francis Wheen · Jim White · Michael White · Roland White · Andreas Whittam Smith · Jamie Whyte · Ann Widdecombe · David Wighton · Peter Wilby · Zoe Williams · John Willman · A.N. Wilson · Quentin Wilson · Claudia Winkleman · Rolfe Winkler · Henry Winter · Jeanette Winterson · Patrick Wintour · Terry Wogan · Naomi Wolf · Martin Wolf · Vicki Woods · Martin Woollacott · Word on the street · The World Reordered · World View · Diana Wright · Jackie Wullschlager · Tim Yeo · Hugo Young · Jimmy Young · Peter York · Gary Younge · Slavoj Žižek

574610 420112098013924 18446820 n.jpg